20150819 - Bill Birnes and Jim Sanders - Live Chat Thread

[PrairieGhost]

Well, I'm just going to have to call tonight.

[trostol]

the problem is..it is 20 years later..most people do not care or have interests invested in other areas

[GeorgieForPresident2216]

Yeah, I could see troop transports or something. But for an aircraft, you'd have to actually physically hit the aircraft with the missile. That's a really tall order, better to just explode nearby and spray shrapnel.

Would you also have to make it adhere to the aircraft somehow while the reaction took place?  And if the aircraft is already hit and disabled, what's the point?

[Herbn-Legend]

Yeah dude. I was a friend of T's and we never got too far out to talk right. You win.

my buddy gru up next door got to smoke with him wen she turnd 13. Now she makez healing jewelry for the family😀mckenna family iz the future if we wanna survive

[Uncle Duke]

I would guess it more likely non US sub missile. I mean, right?

Other than the fact subs don't carry SAMs.  I will ask again, if we assume the video does show a missile, where was the launch point for that missile? 

[trostol]

good luck with that lol

[norland2424]

LOL did they really say a sub shot the flight down?, with no anti air capacity ?

[QuantumMystics]

https://youtu.be/rOqKuTBcqRs

[aldousburbank]

I'm curious how common and/or plausible the "fuel tank explosion" scenario is?

[starrmtn001]

my buddy gru up next door got to smoke with him wen she turnd 13. Now she makez healing jewelry for the family😀mckenna family iz the future if we wanna survive

Like in The Family Jewels??? :

[AppealPlay]

This is a really good show tonight.  I dig it.

Did Jim say if ever tested the material he received for explosive residue or whatever?

[QuantumMystics]

[alienated]

Other than the fact subs don't carry SAMs.  I will ask again, if we assume the video does show a missile, where was the launch point for that missile?

They do now! 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jIGl42ELB_A

[chefist]

I'm curious how common and/or plausible the "fuel tank explosion" scenario is?

Agreed...planes have been flying with empty tanks forever...why was this the first accident attributed to an empty tank?

[Jocko Johnson]

That is marginally within the realm of possibility. MARGINALLY. But absolutely impossible for it to have come from a US platform.

Look eve if this was done by someone, the navy even by a horrible, terrible accident, how could they keep this underwraps with so many people involved. 

[lonevoice]

Yeah dude. I was a friend of T's and we never got too far out to talk right. You win.

Aldous...boom.  Carry on.   

[morgana213]

This is a really good show tonight.  I dig it.

Did Jim say if ever tested the material he received for explosive residue or whatever?

Yep, it is!  Art Bell gold.   

[aldousburbank]

my buddy gru up next door got to smoke with him wen she turnd 13. Now she makez healing jewelry for the family😀mckenna family iz the future if we wanna survive

My best to the family and all my Hawaiian bredren. Be there soon.

[Herbn-Legend]

Like in The Family Jewels??? :

hahahahahahahaha

[FightTheFuture]

Other than the fact subs don't carry SAMs.  I will ask again, if we assume the video does show a missile, where was the launch point for that missile?

Duke, the Russian Kilo class subs are equipped with SAM's.

[Uncle Duke]

LOL did they really say a sub shot the flight down?, with no anti air capacity ?

Yep, but some people don't want to let facts get in the way of a good story.

[aldousburbank]

Duke, the Russian Kilo class subs are equipped with SAM's.

Fuckers

[QuantumMystics]

Flying cigar found!

[Herbn-Legend]

My best to the family and all my Hawaiian bredren. Be there soon.

land iz cheap here again😀 $3000-$20,000 a acre, daom good time to buy in the big island live at 19.5° or 19.4😝

[Uncle Duke]

Duke, the Russian Kilo class subs are equipped with SAM's.

Launchable underwater??  I don't think so, at least not 20 yrs ago.

[FightTheFuture]

Look eve if this was done by someone, the navy even by a horrible, terrible accident, how could they keep this underwraps with so many people involved.

It's impossible. Period.

[AppealPlay]

This is what Bob Crane sounds like?  Neat!  I have to buy one of his products just for supporting Art all these years.

[SciFiAuthor]

Would you also have to make it adhere to the aircraft somehow while the reaction took place?  And if the aircraft is already hit and disabled, what's the point?

Yeah, I mean if you have a missile traveling at high speed intended to hit an aircraft and then stop on a dime so the reaction can take place . . . that's just not going to happen. And that's assuming you can make contact with the aircraft at all.

[FightTheFuture]

Launchable underwater??  I don't think so, at least not 20 yrs ago.

No, they would have to surface, of course.

[norland2424]

Launchable underwater??  I don't think so, at least not 20 yrs ago.

if anything it would be surfaced launched, makes no point of any sub launching a sam underwater