• Welcome to BellGab/bellchan Archive.
 
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - sorlag

#1
Politics / Re: How to Help the Egyptians
February 02, 2011, 05:26:53 PM
Quote from: The General on February 02, 2011, 04:05:24 PM
Considering Ahmadinejad's nuclear aspirations, sposorship of terrorism, hatred of Israel, admiration of Hitler, and denial of the Holocaust, I think it's pretty clear what he's saying.  Do you two share Ahmadinejad's denial of the Holocaust?

And although nuking Japan was a terrible thing to do, it saved more lives than continuing the war would have.  It was a terrible choice to have been faced with, but most people agree it was justified. 

And finally, yes, let's stick to the point which is not Israel vs. Iran, it is a thread about Egypt.  Which, by the way, I am suspicious that Iran may somehow be behind this revolution in Egypt.  This did not happen over night, someone is behind it.

from a neutral stand point and without being biased, Iran's nuclear aspirations are justified even if they are military focused, an IDF officer lately declared that "if Iranians are not seeking nuclear weapons, then they are crazy.", we just invaded Iraq and Afghanistan, Israel invaded Libanon 5 times in the latest decades, we have a major base in SA to whom we sell high tech military gadgets almost daily,  note that SA and Iran are sworn enemies, Israel just deployed German made nuclear  submarines under the whole area, Israel never agreed to any Nuclear weapon non proliferation agreement, and never showed any interest in a nuke free Middle east, not to mention the harsh language with which we talk to Iran and which sounds more like if we actually want them to keep doing what they are doing.
so why would Iranian's or Najad not seek nuclear power? in their shoes, even Alice in wonderland would have looked for Nukes.

in the middle east region, again, only one country has Nukes and its not Iran, if we are sincere in asking Iran not to seek Nukes (no matter how arrogant this sounds considering we do have Nukes), we should start with that country first, otherwise we wouldn't make sense.

Nejad's world were mysteriously twisted on our news to become "death to Israel!", the guy also never declared  that he "Admired" Hitler nor that he was Holocaust denier, he plainly declared to CNN that claims about the Holocaust could be inflated and that he was calling for an international investigation to make things clear once and for all, that does not make him Bin laden nor Hitler nor does it make him public enemy number one.


Egyptian protests didn't come overnight, people protested against Mubarak's tyranny for two decades, (we were just tuned away) but Mubarak, with our blessing and our shielding from international scrutiny and our cash, killed any opposition and silenced any resistance either by cash or by force,  the MB members that you are suggesting is a terrorist organisation, were wrongly charged, imprisoned massively and tortured just for asking for social reform and justice, in the same prisons where Omar Suleiman, the guy who was just promoted from secret service director to VP, used to torture detainees that we couldn't torture on our land in the rendition program that occurred in the last several years.

Arabs know that, they also know because of all the above and more that we only care about Israel and that we dont give a rats arse about them, their nations or their democracy, their media happened to be more liberal and less biased than ours, it seems that they took our words and slogans that we don't follow seriously and become objective and independent, so if they don't trust us very much we should spare the world preposterous comments like: "oh its because they hate our freedom".
#2
Politics / Re: How to Help the Egyptians
February 02, 2011, 02:10:10 PM
Quote from: The General on February 02, 2011, 01:27:15 PM
What human rights groups?  CAIR?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahmoud_Ahmadinejad#Human_rights

Ahmadinejad's stated long term goal is to destroy Israel.  Would you like to see that also?
If Iran nukes Israel, will you agree that it would tarnish their wonderful 'human rights' record?

all of them including btselem which an Israeli HR watchdog.
Ahmadi Nejad is a person, we can compare persons later maybe to someone like Ariel Sharon, but now lets stick to the subject, which is Iran as a state vs Israel as state.
Ahmadi Nejed never stated anything like that, Ahmadi Nejad was Quoting Khomeini as saying:"the occupation regime over Jerusalem should vanish from the page of time."
which is a very legitimate aspiration for such a state, especially that under UN records, Jerusalem is indeed defined as an occupied territory.

the only country in that region with Nukes is Israel, not Iran. and the only country who has ever used nukes on humans is ours.

#3
Politics / Re: How to Help the Egyptians
February 02, 2011, 01:14:05 PM
Quote from: The General on February 02, 2011, 12:40:04 PM
I have no idea how to argue with someone who truly believes that Iran is superior to Israel when it comes to human rights.

i don't believe so, i know so, and so does everyone interested in the subject, and again: all human rights organisations reported so over and over again, compared to Iran, Israel has tarnished human rights record, this is something tangible, concrete and verifiable. Belief has nothing to do with this.
#4
Politics / Re: How to Help the Egyptians
February 02, 2011, 12:23:32 PM
Quote from: The General on January 29, 2011, 01:04:32 PM
Egyptian democracy is a BAD IDEA.  Egytptian democracy will most likely mean a rise to power for the Muslim Brotherhood.  More radical throwback Muslims.  We should be supporting the current government, it may not be perfect but it's better than what will happen there with an overthrow. 

This is almost an exact replay of the revolution in Iran that ousted the Shah and brought in the Ayatollah Khomeini.  The Shah was better than what followed with Islamic radicals.  And Obama is on the wrong side of this revolution, just like Carter undermined the Shah of Iran.  This is a huge mistake.  We should be supporting our friends in the government of Egypt, not the revolutionaries.

Islamic extremists gaining control of Egypt will mean that both sides of the Suez canal will be controlled by throwback Muslims.  Bad news.  How does $10 a gallon gas sound?

thats not true, MB is neither a terrorist organisation nor an extremist group.
we should not be supporting anybody, we should take care of our own business and leave other nations decide what is best for them, and we definitely should not be supporting dictatorships.

this has nothing to do with the revolution in Iran, which by the way, and according to all human rights watchdogs, still holds a better human rights record than the state of Israel which, according to us is a democracy and which we support with our hard earned taxpayer's cash.

Islamic extremists do not have any power in Egypt and have no chance of getting hold of power, no more than the KKK can get hold of power in the USA.

$10 a gallon sounds like we should stop relying on middle east gas, find alternatives and seriously support alternative fuel initiatives.

how does $4 a gallon sound? how does $340 a gallon sound? how does $[insert number] a gallon sound?
should we have a number above which we should sell our souls, forget our values and start killing people?
point is, that is not a valid argument, gas in Europe and Japan has been close to $10 a gallon since forever, yet none of those countries went berserk.
Powered by SMFPacks Menu Editor Mod